The majority of Tewaaraton Award winners have been featured on trading cards over the years. The following is a list of rookie cards for each honoree. In some cases a blanket set, such as 2007 Donruss, 2010 Upper Deck or 2017 Topps Allen & Ginter are listed, when in fact the player has multiple variations or parallel cards within the set.

Men’s Recipients
YearWinnerPositionSchoolRookie Card
2023Brennan O’NeilAttackDuke
2022Logan WisnauskasAttackUniversity of Maryland2022 Topps
2021Jared BernhardtAttackUniversity of Maryland2022 Immaculate Collection Collegiate Football – Immaculate Champions#
2020No Recipient due to Covid-19
2019Patrick SpencerAttackLoyola2020-21 Panini Prizm*
2018Ben ReevesAttackYale2022 Topps
2017Matt RamboAttackUniversity of Maryland2021 Topps
2016Dylan MolloyAttackBrownSports Illustrated for Kids – August, 2016
2015Lyle ThompsonAttackUniversity of Albany2017 Topps Allen & Ginter/2016-17 Georgia Swarm
2014Lyle ThompsonAttackUniversity of Albany2017 Topps Allen & Ginter/2016-17 Georgia Swarm
2014Miles ThompsonAttackUniversity of Albany2016-17 Georgia Swarm
2013Rob PannellAttackCornell2014 New York Lizards
2012Peter BaumAttackColgate
2011Steele StanwickAttackUniversity of Virginia2019 Parkside
2010Ned CrottyMidfieldDuke2010 Upper Deck
2009Max SeibaldAttackCornell2010 Upper Deck
2008Mike LeveilleAttackSyracuse2010 Upper Deck
2007Matt DanowskiAttackDuke2010 Upper Deck
2006Matt WardAttackUniversity of Virginia2007 Washington Bayhawks
2005Kyle HarrisonMidfieldJohns Hopkins2008 Los Angeles Riptide
2004Michael PowellAttackSyracuse2007 Donruss
2003Chris RotelliMidfieldUniversity of Virginia2010 Upper Deck
2002Michael PowellAttackSyracuse2007 Donruss
2001Doug ShanahanMidfieldHofstra2005 Philadelphia Barrage
* This card is part of the Panini Prizm basketball set
# This card is part of the Immaculate Collection Collegiate Football set
Women’s Recipients
YearWinnerPositionSchoolRookie Card
2023Izzy ScaneAttackerNorthwesternSports Illustrated for Kids – July/August, 2023
2022Charlotte NorthAttackerBoston College2022 Topps Allen & Ginter, Allen & Ginter Chrome, Allen & Ginter X, 2023 Topps Athletes Unlimited
2021Charlotte NorthAttackerBoston College2022 Topps Allen & Ginter, Allen & Ginter Chrome, Allen & Ginter X, 2023 Topps Athletes Unlimited
2020No Recipient due to Covid-19
2019Megan TaylorGoalieUniversity of Maryland
2018Sam ApuzzoAttackBoston College2021 Topps Athletes Unlimited
2017Zoe StukenbergMidfieldUniversity of Maryland
2016Taylor CummingsMidfieldUniversity of MarylandSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2014
2015Taylor CummingsMidfieldUniversity of MarylandSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2014
2014Taylor CummingsMidfieldUniversity of MarylandSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2014
2013Katie SchwarzmannMidfieldUniversity of Maryland
2012Katie SchwarzmannMidfieldUniversity of Maryland
2011Shannon SmithAttackerNorthwesternSports Illustrated for Kids – July, 2011
2010Caitlyn McFaddenMidfieldUniversity of Maryland
2009Hannah NielsenMidfieldNorthwesternSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2008
2008Hannah NielsenMidfieldNorthwesternSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2008
2007Kristen KjellmanMidfieldNorthwestern
2006Kristen KjellmanMidfieldNorthwestern
2005Katie ChrestAttackerDukeSports Illustrated for Kids – August, 2008
2004Amy AppeltMidfieldUniversity of Virginia
2003Rachael BeckerDefensePrinceton
2002Erin ElbeAttackerGeorgetownSports Illustrated for Kids – September, 2002
2001Jen AdamsAttackerUniversity of Maryland