- 1987 – Tom Carmean
- 1989 – Sal LoCascio
- 1990
- 1994 – Wes Depp
- 2002 – Marc Morley
- 2003 – Kevin Leveille
- 2004 – Jeff Zywicki
- 2006 – Jake Deane
- 2007 – Brett Garber
- 2008 – Brian Danvers
- 2010 – Bobby Hayes
- 2011 – Casey Rahn
- 2013 – Will Manny
- 2014 – Connor Mooney
- 2016 – Kyle Karaska