- 1989 – Brian Lewis
- 1990 – Chris Connor
- 1991 – Mark Douglas
- 1993 – Dan Reading
- 1994 – Danny Robbins
- 1997 – Andrew Whipple
- 1999 – Scott Hochstadt
- 2000
- 2001 – Andrew Combs, Chris Malone, Pat McGinnis
- 2002
- 2003
- 2004
- 2005 – Joe Walters
- 2006 – Joe Walters
- 2007 – Ray Megill
- 2008 – Max Ritz
- 2009 – Jeff Reynolds
- 2010 – Bryn Holmes
- 2011 – Brian Farrell
- 2012 – David Miller
- 2013 – Landon Carr
- 2014 – Michael Ehrhardt
- 2015 – Casey Ikeda
- 2016 – Matt Dunn
- 2017 – Tim Muller
- 2018 – Connor Kelly
- 2019 – Curtis Corley
- 2020 – Jared Bernhardt