- 1984 Notre Dame – Rob Simpson & Justin Shay
- 1985 – Bob Trocchi & Justin Shay
- 1986 Notre Dame – Tom Grote & Mike Rice
- 1987 – Dave O’Neill & Wally Stack
- 1988 – Tom Lanahan, John McNicholas & Art Brady
- 1989 – Kevin O’Connor, John Olmstead & Doug Spencer
- 1994 – Randy Colley
- 1996 – Brian Erickson
- 2010 – Sam Barnes
- 2010 – Neal Hicks
- 2011 – David Earl
- 2011 – Kevin Ridgway
- 2011 – Andrew Irving
- 2012 – Eric Keppeler
- 2012 – Mike Pfeiffer
- 2013 – John Kemp
- 2013 – Steve Murphy
- 2014 – Westy Hopkins
- 2014 – Stephen O’Hara
- 2015 – Jack Near
- 2015 – Conor Doyle
- 2015 – Jim Marlatt
- 2016 – Conor Kelly
- 2016 – Jack Sheridan
- 2016 – Kyle Trolley
- 2017 – Garrett Epple
- 2017 – Sergio Perkovic
- 2018 – John Sexton
- 2018 – Mikey Wynne