- 1994
- 2004 – Conor Ford
- 2005 – Matt Rewkowski
- 2007 – Jake Byrne
- 2008 – George Castle
- 2009 – Michael Evans
- 2010 – Michael Kimmel
- 2011
- 2012
- 2013 – Zach Palmer
- 2014 – Ryan Matthews
- 2015 – Wells Stanwick
- 2016 – Ryan Brown
- 2017 – Shack Stanwick
- 2018 – Kyle Marr
- 2019 – Cole Williams