| YEAR | BRAND | SET | SERIES | NUM. | NOTES |
| 1998 | New York Saints | Schedule | NNO | Bud Light sponsor. Wearing #3 | |
| 2001 | MLL | Major League Lacrosse | NNO | Colsey is one of six Bridgeport Barrage players in this 36-card set | |
| 2005 | Philadelphia Barrage | Team Issued Set | 3 | ||
| 2010 | Upper Deck | World of Sports | Base | 277 | Card actually depicts Casey Powell |
| 2019 | Parkside | Major League Lacrosse | Base / MLL Alumni | 107 | |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Base | 88 | Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Matte | 88 | Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Black & White | 88 | #/50, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Gold | 88 | #1/1, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Green | 88 | #/2, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Red | 88 | #/10, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Black | 88 | #/25, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Orange | 88 | #/50, Coach – Carolina |
| 2026 | PLL | Fieldside II | Blue | 88 | #/99, Coach – Carolina |