| YEAR | BRAND | SET | SERIES | NUM. | NOTES |
| 1992/93 | Jan’s Smoke Shop | Buffalo Bandits Pog Sheet | O’Toole is one of five players plus the Bandits team logo as pogs on a perforated sheet | ||
| 2000 | ROOX | 2000 NLL Championship | 9 | Sponsored by Warburg Pincus Funds | |
| 2007 | CHOICE SportsCards | Rochester Knighthawks | 2 | Given out on 2-17-07 vs. Portland LumberJax | |
| 2016 | Zweigle’s | Rochester Knighthawks | NNO | Assistant Coach |